You might well ask, where was I after my admission four months ago of having gone AWOL, lo - I go and do it again. What can I say, it has been a busy time for me.
When last we met I was sharing the photos that I had submitted to the Orkney Camera Club. There was the entry for the Monthly Competition theme of Pattern/Texture. I had some success in the Colour Digital section, gaining a Third place on my first time out. I was well pleased.
The feedback overall was good, though I learned that it is not always easy to take, especially when one's own favourites are criticised by the judge. It took some backbone to swallow it down and acknowledge that not everybody thinks my babies are beautiful.
Tastes differ. I took from the feedback what I needed and put the rest down to taste! I believe it is important, if committed to an image, not to be swayed by differing opinions. It is okay to hang on to that mother love. There is no right in this, only opinion. Where feedback is most important is with those images that leave a small voice in the gut whispering that something is not quite harmonious here. That voice knows and the judge's feedback can help us to grow - not to mention identifying just what it was that was bothering us about that particular image...
That third place gave me sufficient confidence to try again in the second Monthly Competition, with the theme of "Myself", I entered another six images.
What do you know, I was placed third in the colour digital class again.
Perhaps less taken with the judge's comments this time - some of them stung! Overall it was clear that we did not share a mindset.
Being short of time for M3, Playing With Scale, I scratched around a bit to fill in the set at the last moment.
I had planned to do a colour trio based on the song from The Sound of Music - the Tonic Sol Fa mnemonic, Do, a Deer, a female deer.... tra, la, la. I held the idea that when we went to Scotland in the Autumn, I might get a shot of a nice Doe, and I also wanted to do Fa (Far) and knew just the stretch of road that I wanted to shoot. Alas, when we arrived at the iconic spot, roadworks stopped play. Deer were nowhere to be seen in the whole trip. I was left with an idea for So (Sew), and one for Te (Tea) and these two shots I set up at home in a makeshift studio. I was very pleased with Te (Tea). I still am.
As it turned out, Te was the only one of the six images not placed! The scratch images did better than the planned ones. Life's funny, isn't it?
Perhaps there is such a thing as trying too hard?
The judge's comments overall were kind and sympathetic and I feel that he was more simpatico with this photographer than the previous two judges.
Tardis Landing: Interesting uncertainty about how big the box is compared to its setting. Atmospheric, fun and interesting to analyse. 1st
So, a Needle Pulling Thread: Nice idea. Well set up and taken. Too much space around it? But maybe that helps the impression that the needle is much bigger and stronger than it actually is. 2nd
Te, a Drink with Jam and Bread: Nicely set up and taken. A nice clean feel to it. Can’t see a link to the theme. Unplaced
Dual Scale: Very simple idea and works well. The inclusion of numbers and the idea of measurement take you towards the idea of scale, added to by the differential focus and extreme perspective. 1st
Pod Plays Double or Drop: Interesting idea and well executed. Idea of scale comes from a small figure doing a job too big for it and becoming overwhelmed by objects that are miniature versions of the real thing. 2nd
1 to 76: Deceptively simple. Model locomotive looks real at first glance then other parts of the image reveal it isn’t. Cropping is a bit puzzling? 3rd
Not surprisingly, I was overwhelmed by this result!
Last week's meeting had the results from two of the club's Battles and Exchanges programme. I still don't understand what the difference is or how these work but I am sure all will become clear in time. (See post passim for what was entered to the OCC for consideration for inclusion in the programme.
I enquired yesterday how things had gone and was kindly sent the results in return. In the Whitton/Orkney event (what/where is Whitton?) OCC had entered four of my images
We lost, but only slightly - 433.5 to 438. The images were scored out of twenty points each and feedback given:
I could scarcely have hoped for better than that, could I - scoring 73.5 out of a possible 80 for my club. I'm more than happy with that. Especially happy that the Falconer did so well as that is one that I love and am proud of. I don't often shoot people as I lack confidence in that area but I would love to do more of this "environmental portrait" type of work - people captured doing whatever is is that they are passionate about.
The Falconer. Beautifully captured. Timing spot on. The bird with outstretched wings fills the out of focus background nicely. The stillness of the man and the intensity of his gaze suggesting the eventual attention of the raptor to its prey. 20 points
QWERTY. It just goes to show that anything can make a photograph, if you have the imagination to see it. It does take a particular brain and eye to see the potential of this sort of shot. Abstracts are not easy. Well done. 18.5 points
In the Stream. Quite beautiful. Serene, muted colours go well together. Exposure well held. A nice sense of movement. 18 points
Teasels. Nicely seen or set up. Exposure and lighting is sympathetic to the subject. Soft and atmospheric. The wall on the left is out of focus and rather disturbing to look at. 17 points
It looks as though I had three images entered for the club in this event: Veined, as shown in M1 Pattern/Texture (see up this page), Been through the Mill was also a Black and White entry in M1 and additionally Crovie Woman, not shown elsewhere.
I was not so successful in Shetland, where we lost narrowly again 316 to 323, but still a fair showing, I reckon and I knocked up 49 out of a possible 60 for my club:
Been through the mill but still standing: Standing .. Isaac Newton, Something Will Turn Up. Charles Dickens. Very attractive monochrome macro. Even better if some theme."On Up Standing"?? 17 points
Crovie woman: Crovie E of Banff - physically can't get a road. Somebody else's artwork. Have to look at value add: quality, monochrome, feel texture of wood. More marks if not SEA. 16 points
Veined: Beautiful pattern shot of fern fronds. Bright and colourful. Would be improved if more was in focus - only middle left and bottom in focus. 16 points
Well, I learned something there! SEA - someone else's art. It never occurred to me that taking a beautiful photo of something wonderful would be penalised for that reason - but at least I added some value. Must be sure not to enter such in the future.
This judge echoed the M1 judge. I may have to concede the point now! However, I cropped it for reasons of balance and actually enjoy the graduated focus effect that came with that so am still in love with it and will not be swayed on that point. File it under "Well, I like it".
As for Been Through the Mill... I am not going to argue with the judge on that one. That image was originally named Upstanding. I renamed it for the Texture comp to draw attention to the milled edge texture connection to the theme. Being slightly inept with Lightroom I managed to carry forward that name instead of reverting to the original when I exported the copy for submission. I am officially An Idiot.
I now have until 23rd March to pick my entries for the Annual Competition, then there are further exchange results to come on the 20th April. I've started the Annual selection but it's wearying work and I lose the ability to look critically at my my images after a short while. There is a lot going on here too, and taking up most of my time. I shall do my best not to forget though.